If you're looking to level up your defense in MLB The Show 25, mastering defensive shifts is a game-changer. While pitching and hitting get most of the spotlight, a well-timed shift can completely shut down an opponent's momentum. In this guide, we’ll explore 8 of the most effective defensive shifts you can apply, especially in online matchups where every out counts.

Whether you're grinding Ranked Seasons or aiming to dominate in Battle Royale, strategic fielding makes a huge difference—just as much as when you buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs to boost your squad. Let’s dig in.

1. Extreme Pull vs. Left-Handed Hitters

Use this shift when facing left-handed sluggers known for pulling ground balls. Slide your infield right, putting the second baseman in shallow right field. This alignment eats up those hard pull shots before they reach the outfield. It works well against players like Kyle Schwarber or Max Muncy.

2. Extreme Pull vs. Right-Handed Hitters

Similar to the previous one, but flipped for righties. Shift your infield left and keep your third baseman deep. Power hitters like Pete Alonso are great targets for this shift. Just make sure your pitcher keeps the ball inside.

3. No Doubles Alignment

Activate this shift in late innings with a slim lead. It pulls your outfielders closer to the lines and deeper overall. This strategy reduces the risk of extra-base hits and is perfect for tight spots when a double could cost you the game.

4. Bunt Defense Shift

If you’re up against someone abusing bunts with speedy hitters, toggle this shift. It brings your corner infielders up and adjusts positioning to cut off bunt singles. It’s especially helpful in Road to the Show or Ranked when you run into “small ball” specialists.

5. Infield In (Runners on 3rd)

When there’s a runner on third and you need to stop a run at home, bring your infield in. This shift prioritizes the plate over potential outs at first. It’s risky—grounders get through more easily—but it can win you tight ballgames.

6. Standard vs. Balanced Hitters

Not every situation demands a shift. For balanced hitters with spray tendencies, the standard alignment is your safest bet. It keeps your defense flexible and avoids unnecessary gaps. It’s a reminder that sometimes default positioning is the smartest call.

7. Double Play Depth

Use this shift with runners on first and less than two outs. Your middle infielders move closer to second base, making it easier to turn two. It’s especially effective in clutch moments where you need quick outs to stop momentum.

8. Outfield Shift Right or Left

This isn’t used as often, but shifting your outfield right or left based on hitter tendencies can save you crucial extra-base hits. Check your scouting reports in-game—if someone constantly drives balls to the opposite field, make the necessary adjustment.

Defensive shifting isn’t just about stats—it’s about knowing your opponent and reacting with precision. While smart positioning can save runs, pairing it with a solid roster is just as important. If you’re trying to boost your team without breaking the bank, sites offering cheap MLB The Show 25 stubs for sale can help accelerate that grind. Many players rely on trustworthy platforms like U4N to buy MLB The Show 25 stubs safely and efficiently.

Ultimately, defense wins championships—even in The Show. Learn your shifts, mix them up, and keep your opponents guessing.